“Indian giver” seemed in print in different instances within the early 1800’s, particularly in the USA, within the sense discussed in Starting place.
Alternatively, through the years, the meaning of the expression shifted towards its fresh figuring out of an individual that reclaims items that got away.
The importance of “Indian giver” didn’t subside within the 20th century, final a powerful idiomatic word smartly into the 2000’s.
It used to be first outlined on City Dictionary in 2003, with numerous different entries to practice.