When the idea that of an Obscurus was once presented, enthusiasts eternally speculated about Harry. In truth, the query cropped up so ceaselessly that Wizarding Global writer J.Okay. Rowling added it to the “FAQs” segment of her site.
Whilst rising up, Harry lived with the Dursleys, who now not best actively hated magic but in addition repeatedly abused their nephew. However despite the fact that the recipe is apparently there for him to expand an Obscurus, it by no means occurs. It’s because probably the most pivotal piece of the components is the acknowledgment and next suppression of magic, which does not occur with Harry.
“The Dursleys had been too terrified of magic ever to recognize its lifestyles to Harry,” Rowling wrote. “Whilst Vernon and Petunia had a at a loss for words hope that in the event that they had been nasty sufficient to Harry his unusual skills may someway evaporate, they by no means taught him to be ashamed or fearful of magic. Even if he was once scolded for ‘making issues occur’, he did not make any strive to suppress his true nature, nor did he ever believe that he had the facility to achieve this.”
General, it sort of feels that Rowling put concept into the idea that and it is paid off. In a Reddit submit by means of u/sweetpotato37 asking if others dislike the Obscurus storyline within the “Implausible Beasts” collection, a number of Redditors felt the other, pointing to Albus Dumbledore’s sister, Ariana, who’s showed to be an Obscurial in “Implausible Beasts: The Secrets and techniques of Dumbledore.”
Redditor u/palcatraz had the most well liked resolution, announcing partially, “Within the unique books, we already had Ariana’s tale, during which a tender magical kid is mindful of and tries to suppress her magic with horrible effects. I see the [O]bscurus tale line as an extension of the idea that we already had been presented [to] by the use of Ariana’s tale.”