“Harry Potter” fanatics took to Reddit to talk about Sirius Black’s extremely unhappy personality arc, and that’s the reason the place other folks chimed in, evaluating Lupin’s difficult destiny to Black’s. In a stunning flip of occasions that you do not see in maximum fandoms, the controversy was once very civil, with customers merely mentioning info to argue their viewpoints.
U/SuperSiriusBlack started the dialogue, bringing up Sirius’ backstory to spice up his argument. U/Ash3070 put issues into viewpoint, mentioning, “JK Rowling later published that Sirius’s twenty first birthday would’ve been the day after he was once despatched to Azkaban. HAPPY BIRTHDAY!” U/AllHailTheNod agreed to the observation, including that Sirius spent his quick pre-prison existence with a circle of relatives that hated him, then his best good friend betrayed him, after which Dementors tortured him for over a decade for a criminal offense he did not dedicate.
The publish supplies a powerful argument for Sirius, however Lupin fanatics rallied to provide an explanation for his similarly tragic saga. An identical to the unique publish, u/aveclesmuguets gave a rundown of Lupin’s existence tale, revealing his a lot of struggles containing his lycanthropy and the PTSD he handled after preventing towards Voldemort’s forces as a tender grownup and as an older wizard. U/lettersfromowls introduced up that Lupin slowly watched all of his closest buddies die and had to care for that trauma on my own. U/handicapableofmaths argued that Dumbledore principally deserted Lupin till he discovered a use for him. U/Amata69 spotted an identical remedy, writing, “I ponder whether, say, McGonagall remembered her former scholar who has misplaced all his buddies and puzzled how on earth he was once managing.”
Irrespective of what aspect fanatics select, it is transparent that each Sirius and Lupin went via so much. We will’t lend a hand however agree that they each deserved extra happiness.
