In a Reddit thread, u/sanguinalis shared a way of sadness after looking at “Black Swan,” discovering the movie “terrible.” The person defined, “I do know everybody simply went nuts for this movie, however except incredible cinematography I assumed it used to be predictable and pretentious.” Bringing up the storyline as an “glaring” narrative that pointed obviously to Nina’s mental unraveling, the person additionally thought to be the “Swan Lake” thread unoriginal, leading to a “false veneer used to make it seem that the movie is deep and existential, when truly it is an outdated concept that has been completed prior to and completed a lot better.”
Redditor u/JBNY agreed with the complaint, noting, “The symbolism by no means made any sense, or it used to be so to your face that it ruined the theory of what symbolism is meant to be.” The person additionally argued that the movie suffered on account of Portman’s efficiency, writing, “The primary personality turns out to by no means truly say anything else, simply makes a large number of facial expressions.” Emphasizing the similar level, u/crass0405 mentioned, “Natalie Portmans facial features vary went from ‘I am about to cry,’ to, ‘I am about to make the I am about to cry face.'”
Additionally, those similar audience have been a long way from on my own of their overview. All over the movie’s liberate, David Edelstein, a critic for NPR, referred to as “Black Swan” a “in large part empty sensation.” The similar reviewer lamented the movie’s loss of appreciate for the ballet occupation, writing, “I have by no means observed a dance movie with so little appreciation for the artwork of dance.”
After all, it’s transparent that no longer everybody sought after an encore of “Black Swan,” even with its in depth acclaim.